Welcome to Claws
Claws, located in West Sayville, NY, is a seafood market offering a variety of fresh and delicious dishes. Known for their Lobster Rolls, such as the Naked Roll with pure lobster meat and drawn butter, and the Double Roll with an abundance of lobster, Claws delivers quality seafood options. Customers praise the creamy Clam Chowder and the savory Crab Cake Sandwich. The casual yet charming atmosphere, coupled with friendly staff, makes dining at Claws a delightful experience. Whether you're a seafood enthusiast or just looking for a satisfying meal, Claws is a must-visit destination for seafood lovers.
- 20 Main St West Sayville, NY 1179620 Main St West Sayville, NY 11796 Hotline: (631) 256-5900
Welcome to Claws, a hidden gem nestled along the serene waters of West Sayville, New York, where seafood lovers find their paradise. Specializing in fresh, quality seafood, Claws takes pride in delivering an exceptional dining experience in a relaxed atmosphere. The quaint setting features inviting picnic-style tables surrounded by lush bamboo, providing the perfect oasis for those looking to enjoy a delightful meal while soaking in the natural beauty of the area.
At Claws, the star of the show is, without a doubt, their lobster rolls. The Naked Roll, priced at $22, showcases the essence of fresh lobster meat, beautifully coupled with drawn butter, offering a simplistic yet luxurious experience. For those with a hearty appetite, the Double Roll is a must-try, boasting nearly three-quarters of a pound of succulent lobster meat at $39. This signature offering has garnered rave reviews, solidifying Claws as the go-to place for lobster enthusiasts.
But the menu doesn't stop at lobster rolls. Seafood lovers will also relish the delectable Classic Fried Shrimp, priced at $15, known for being sweet, all-natural, and free from additives. Meanwhile, meat lovers will be pleased with options like the Claw Burger, a perfectly fire-grilled Angus beef patty seasoned with bay spices for just $10. With flavorful choices from both the land and sea, Claws ensures that every guest finds something to love.
The ambiance at Claws is equally delightful, as highlighted by customer reviews. Patrons like Laurie G. have praised the friendly staff and the picturesque outdoor seating available in a cozy tented area. This inviting environment enhances your meal, making each visit feel like a favorite seasonal getaway. Whether you’re enjoying a bowl of creamy clam chowder, which is as comforting as it is filling, or savoring a crab meat sandwich, each dish is prepared with care and quality ingredients.
As I reflect on my experience at Claws, I am filled with excitement to return. The combination of fresh seafood, delightful ambiance, and top-notch service creates a dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more. It’s clear that Claws is more than just a seafood market; it's a community hub for lovers of all things maritime. So whether you’re dining in or planning a special seafood bake for an occasion, Claws is an essential stop for unforgettable seafood dishes.
So, if you find yourself in the vicinity of 20 Main St, West Sayville, or are seeking a charming locale for your next meal, grab your friends, embrace the relaxed vibe, and dive into the sea of flavors waiting at Claws.

I've passed claws a number of times but was always hesitant based on the limited parking. The parking lot is big enough for about 6 cars, and although there is street parking, if the surrounding restaurants are busy it is quite a task finding a spot. However once your in the staff was very friendly and helpful. The little area they have nestled by the side of the water is very quaint. There was a small amount of seating in a fully covered and walled tent and then outdoor plastic picnic tables. As you sit outside you are surrounded in a nice little oasis of bamboo and other water side foliage with ducks walking around. The vibe here is very relaxed but fun. The food was great. We tried two different lobster rolls, clams on the half shell and some other things. The food was excellent. If you are in the area or want a cute little outdoor area to dine, Claws is a great place to try.

Solid spot for a great sandwich or fish dish. We have went there a few times now and really enjoyed the quality of the seafood. The clam chowder has a nice creamy texture and is well stocked so it leaves you full even before your main dish. If you still have room, their crab meat sandwich is really solid and always hits the spot. I love the low key ambience too as the picnic like tables and circular seating under the outside umbrellas is really nice for a spring/summer meal.

Haven't gotten a lobster roll at Claws in a long time. Hands down the best. We have a place in MTK and love our lobster! Great job Claws!

The seafood is always fresh, variety is the best I've seen and the chowder is to die for.

Been to Claws pre-pandemic to have one of their lobster rolls and from what I remember, it was really effin' good. But for this review, I'll base it off of our seafood bake that we had for Christmas Eve, our Feast of the Seven fishes. When my mom told me she was planning on getting this for the festivities, I'm not going to lie, I was a tad bummed. We usually all brought a fish or two. This year, everyone was sick or had a tough time so it just made sense to grab this special. I went with my mom during the day to pick up our preordered bake and pickup was a breeze. This seafood bake had everything from mussels, clams and shrimp to crab legs, calamari and scallops. The crab legs were my favorite. This was a great order and made me want to cater from Claws in the future. Maybe one day I will. Here's to coming back more in the summer months for those delicious rolls.

I've been going to claws for a couple years now and it's always been consistent. The prices have gone up but that's to be expected with inflation. They have a good selection of seafood you can order that's caught in the USA, these prices are higher than other seafood that's caught in India,Indonesia, Peru. So you're paying for quality. You can also order takeout which I've had the salmon and fish and chips. Both were reasonably priced and tasted very good

Love Claws. Seems super fresh. Very casual if you eat there, some picnic tables outdoors. You order at the pick up window and they give you a buzzer to know when your order is ready. Have also gotten seafood to cook at home for seafood boils. So so good! They clean and prepare the items. Their Claws seasoning was a great addition to the boil. Also highly recommend the cocktail sauce.

Cute little spot been meaning to try. My friend got the classic double roll with fries and I got the naked roll with coke slaw. The rolls are filled with plenty of delicious lobster meat and their slaw and fries were delicious. You probably can't beat this price anywhere on Long Island! We also tried the New England clam chowder which was unremarkable. I asked if I was allowed to feed the duck and the bus boy told me he doesn't care so I did and then got scolded for it lol overall 4 stars. You won't be disappointed.

Had a few more good meals here lately, especially this past week. Got the salmon meal without salt this time and it was perfect with just the butter and lemon. Also got a side of coleslaw which is delicious!